Excellent article, yes it is time for the deferent doves to take over. Arrogance and conceit from the medical profession and their institutions can be as damaging as any illness, the medical hawks are reluctant to evaluate before taking action and then they refuse to acknowledge their mistakes so will repeat them. The old saying still holds true fools rush in where angels fear to tread. Thank you Dr Craig for being a voice of reason!
Thank you, Dr Craig well said. Great article reading👏👍.
Ethical pillars; first do no harm and informed consent are distant memories only to be replaced by single narratives and deafening silence notably during & post covid era.
I believe the attitudes you describe (both to emphasise the benefits of new products -and ignore their risks - and to supress challenges to the accepted narative) are the dirct result of financial incentives (for government budgets, achedemics, medical practitioners, media owners and journalists).
The media responce may also have been supported by a propaganda campaign by the military (as people feared SARS-CoV-2 leaked from a biowepons facility).
Just follow the money. If it wasn't for substack the whole bizarre rigmarole would be ignored. Most just want to forget, grit their teeth and pay the debt.
Unfortunately the hubris of those that claimed there was only one way to respond to the threat, was not restrictive or harmful to them and for many was highly beneficial and profitable. The taste of totalitarian power proved intoxicating, twisting their sense of humanity to blind them to the harms they were causing.
Even now they pretend to have acted morally and the NHS still pushes the harmful jab to deny the folly of the policy.
Exactly! Out here in Santa Cruz, California we labor under the willfully ignorant authoritarian diktat of a mini-tyrant calling herself the county "Health officer". Enforcing a mask mandate in healthcare facilities for Fall and Winter. Still pushing the jabs as "The Best" protection. Threatening jail and fines for non-compliance. When questioned doesn't she answer until an answer is requested. Then she spits insultingly with boilerplate nonsense that addresses exactly zero of the concerns raised. It hasn't ended folks. Not by a long shot.
I've exposed crimes against humanity at the Scottish COVID Inquiry since October 2023 and now when i turn my attention to the UK COVID Inquiry often touted as a whitewash i start to find the same evidence. I cannot for the life of me work out why popular ''medical freedom'' community advocates with MILLIONS of followers between them have not been all over these testimonies. So i ask do we have many doves disgusied as hawks or are there any real white doves left at all? i have my doubts.
It most certainly is THE most important Substack, just stating the facts. The others are loving the attention & looking for the coin from the gullible,imo. Try giving Club Grubbery a go here in Oz with Graham Hood & John Larter or Michael Grey Griffith. This is a battle for humanity.
Very well said Roc. It's a big 'awake' club too. That can clearly be seen on who they support, repost, interview etc Think about it. The lockdown sceptics and protestors from 2020-2021 now have all the official evidence they were right and in 2024 decide to look the other way. https://biologyphenom.substack.com/p/newexclusiveannes-law-consultation
At the end of the day what happened in care homes is the root of the 'pandemic' and therefore exposes the jabs were never required to begin therefore is the bigger crime. All now proven through witness statements from an official public inquiry which has been largely ignored by the world's media including 'alternative' UNLIKE the danger jabs which is an approved narrative. Just scrolled your main page and learned absolutely nothing.
EXAMPLE - ''Dr yeadon…is a fucking shill, he talked about flu, when we were doing coronaviruses”.
Dr yeadon is a shill, he is a shill what a mother fucking shill!!”.
No Hubris here: "The Most important free Substack". "No. Mine is". No. You're wrong. Mine is". "That's not true. Mine is". I'm sorry guys but you embarrass yourselves with this pissing contest. And Dr. Clare deserves better in the comments addressing her fine work. Just my opinion. Carry on.
It's callled having a sense of humour. It IS the ONLY substack in the world consistently documenting the world's only official COVID inquiry to reveal the truth to the lockdown hearing directly from families. Pretty important stuff in my eyes. Maybe you should take some time to study it and report back on the evidence vs mocking people that are trying to reveal THE truth to the ''COVID'' pandemic. Merry xmas! Have another red pill on me you look like you haven't woken up enough yet.
There is nothing i've seen on your page i didn't already know and have you ever thought maybe it's you who is effected by ''the darkforce'' given the state of your comments?
''JJ coey is a prick, and so is Dr yeadon. ''
You have the most important free substack in the world? Ok mate. We will agree to disagree.
"creating a culture where doctors fail to lead." indeed - the abdication of responsibility and acceptance of the premise that managers manage better than doctors - as if there were a binary choice. Doctors who have good leadership skills should be leading the whole operation with middle managers following orders from people who have clinical experience. Doctors have let this happen, just as PAs and AAs are starting to gain traction in the UK. Sadly there are too many perverse incentives messing things up. Not enough critical thinking of what works, what doesn't, what gives maximal benefit to the patient for least cost. NICE should be a beacon of efficiency, but instead that system isn't working (else cheap repurposed drugs would have been used during "covid". And economies would not have been shut down in the vain hope of postponing a few elderly lives by 6 months. And perhaps NICE is run by those with strong connections to big pharma, who knows.
I am now 80+ years old. in fair health for my age. I have worked every day until retirement ( forced) from the age of 12 the corner store , meat market and drug store at the same time. I have worked the most foul jobs, loud noise and dirty. smelling of forming oil and smoke. even working with walking pneumonia.
Only retiring because I suffered a damaged back when hit by a car and had to take pain medication. Fords told me I couldn't work because of insurance problems taking pain meds and programming robots. I also worked on my cousins farm every summer until I joined the Navy. I was exposed to everything. even cowpox which left me immune to small pox.
I had every pox and cold virus I caught from my school mates. we went to school sick or not. I tell you this because we as humans must develop our own immune system. injection of an immune response developed in a test tube doesn't work well. nature designed our immune system by millions of years of trial and error. what didn't work was discarded.
Today however it isn't our health that determines what we get. it is profits. when they find something that works well or not it is handed out. then government steps in and regulates it. telling all that it will make us healthier. when it is accepted by the people ignorant of any side effects it becomes a mandate so that we cant refuse treatment. the cost at the start could be missed days of school or a fine for child neglect. now it has all become weaponized.
Covid is the latest example. while it did spread quickly. ( all too quickly for a normal virus ) and did result in some people dying a cure was demanded (to save the world) We were told that it was deadly. (not offering data ) and they were rushing to create the shots to prevent it.
Shortcuts were taken and when one was found it was rushed into production "to save the world" it would be free to all. ( not free but paid for by our taxes ) and all in the panic caused by government propaganda were given the shots. Without proof of it working people ( some who couldnt offer refusal ) were dying without being exposed to the virus.
This was hidden from the people. They continued to Regulate. people who got the virus found it survivable and some didnt even know they had it. proof that nature provided its own way to deal with the virus. government not letting a good crisis go to waste made the shots as a mandate.
Then using misused power it forced companies to demand complience or they would loose their job. Many did and it ruined the lives of many. devorice loss of homes businesses. our rights violated without consequences. Now the WHO wants to have power to demand our complience from a group of people we didnt elect that would take actions up and including military actions if we dont follow their orders.
Again we see the "regulations" put in place to insure our safety. using our health and the rest of the world as reason. They no longer need proof because they have power. power we granted them. power to impose fines and controls that could destroy our nation. I now sit here in disblief on how our nation has gone from relitive freedom to a controling government of both national and world control without resistance.
Control given from fear. developed from the ignorence we have allowed from, again "regulations" that made education "available " to the underprivileged. Our health should be the one thing that is totaly under our control. Now with government "regulations" that become mandates that when not followed become criminal offences.
We still have a choice time to find the reasons for them and who makes these mandates. We must have accountability for our represenatives who willingly violate our rights to have power and control. I lived quite well with out all government mandates. we dont need our lives planned out each step of the way. sorry for being so long in my post. thanks for reading.--------- I, Grampa
Thank you for sharing your experiences and what you learned from them. Our "health" and other aspects of our lives are indeed controlled. You are a hearty person, surviving many assaults.
Thanks Dr. Clare for sharing this insight. The Hawks and Doves... the Hubris of the Hawks. "People without medical training tend to be hawks about medicine", I surely connect with that statement. Even in my own family I have seen and lamented the truth and consequences of that.
Well said Clare. Spot on in all points. Society has been 'dumbed down' for decades and our unconscionable government's going along stock and barrel. Keep up the great work.
A thought-provoking perspective. I agree with the basic idea that pharmaceutical-type intervention vs natural healing or an intervention not likely to cause harm. The pharm industry is indeed way out of hand. Knowledge of healing through letting nature taking a non-dangerous course, or herbs when safe, or food used in an ayurvedic way, has been substantially diminshed to a minority of specialists. In the US this is only rarely allowed in the medical industry. Therefore, expensive. I see the hawk problem though as being caused by extreme powers far above the control and even the knowledge of health care providers, rather than being a direction that providers have taken. Censorship and harsh penalties are used to prevent knowledge and informed response. Leaving the fight to doctors alone won't solve the problem. On a second point, I take issue with the terms "hawk" and "dove". They are biased because of their connotations. I would prefer labels that are descriptive rather than editorial. Nevertheless your concept of "medicine" and public "health" having gone aggressive and harmful is true to my way of thinking.
Super comment Will!! eg-The Scottish COVID inquiry revealled to the world clear as day what the 'COVID pandemic' really was and even THAT cannot muster a collaborative and strong resistance to the false narratives from 2020 which largely have survived in tact. The Scottish evidence i find is consciously AVOIDED by the 'truther/alt media/freedom' community and those that have said something it's token coverage. So many seem to have an agenda self serving or otherwise. Accountability is miles off because no one really wants it. Many happy to take their pieces of silver though ''exposing the truth.''
''“Every kingdom divided against itself is brought to desolation, and every city or house divided against itself will not stand. '' - Jesus--Matthew--2:25
I agree completely especially in relation to the popular ''freedom'' influencers who remember ARE profiteering quite well from being in this space. Also Neil Oliver's point blank refusal to draw attention to the Scottish COIVD inquiry health and social care closing statements occuring in Edinburgh just 36 miles away from his doorstep in Stirling is extremely revealling. A historian saying nought about all that?!! Wow! I notice GBN just uploaded a new video with Neil about FLOURIDE IN USA tap water and how he is 'stunned.' But CONFIRMED human rights abuses, torture and death of his fellow Scots. Meh? I'll give that a pass. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SRh2I_gK0Uk&ab_channel=GBNews
It isnt paranormal but is evil. I have watched for decades as our children have been "dumed down and taught the facts that government is the answer to all their problems. because so many now that include two to three generations have become dependant upon government that they go willingly for anything gov. says. I have been stifled and even arrested for daring to stand and speak up having documented proof of my statements. Media is no longer a forum we can depend upon to didtribute facts and demand accountability. I now 80 and have so many miles behind me and few left to travel must depend upon others to carry on. I am gled you are there and know what is true. I do hope you find a way to get the words out that will show all the facts you know. I see the major problem is that people dont want to know. they are sadisfied in living their lives in a controled fall, depending upon government to "save" them. One thing you may try to overcome that silence. your words must be newsworthy. something they cant resist at not being first to publish. I am not skilled at knowing what that is. I am sorry. Thank you for your efforts----- I, Grampa
This is a powerful piece of writing. Ethical, empowering, insightful. Bravo and thank you.
Thank you, Clare, for this poignant summary.
Excellent article, yes it is time for the deferent doves to take over. Arrogance and conceit from the medical profession and their institutions can be as damaging as any illness, the medical hawks are reluctant to evaluate before taking action and then they refuse to acknowledge their mistakes so will repeat them. The old saying still holds true fools rush in where angels fear to tread. Thank you Dr Craig for being a voice of reason!
Thank you, Dr Craig well said. Great article reading👏👍.
Ethical pillars; first do no harm and informed consent are distant memories only to be replaced by single narratives and deafening silence notably during & post covid era.
The big pharma shackles ...🤑🤑
"Deafening silence". I like your introduction of this term.
I believe the attitudes you describe (both to emphasise the benefits of new products -and ignore their risks - and to supress challenges to the accepted narative) are the dirct result of financial incentives (for government budgets, achedemics, medical practitioners, media owners and journalists).
The media responce may also have been supported by a propaganda campaign by the military (as people feared SARS-CoV-2 leaked from a biowepons facility).
Just follow the money. If it wasn't for substack the whole bizarre rigmarole would be ignored. Most just want to forget, grit their teeth and pay the debt.
You wrote more succinctly that I did about the same ideas. Well said.
Unfortunately the hubris of those that claimed there was only one way to respond to the threat, was not restrictive or harmful to them and for many was highly beneficial and profitable. The taste of totalitarian power proved intoxicating, twisting their sense of humanity to blind them to the harms they were causing.
Even now they pretend to have acted morally and the NHS still pushes the harmful jab to deny the folly of the policy.
Exactly! Out here in Santa Cruz, California we labor under the willfully ignorant authoritarian diktat of a mini-tyrant calling herself the county "Health officer". Enforcing a mask mandate in healthcare facilities for Fall and Winter. Still pushing the jabs as "The Best" protection. Threatening jail and fines for non-compliance. When questioned doesn't she answer until an answer is requested. Then she spits insultingly with boilerplate nonsense that addresses exactly zero of the concerns raised. It hasn't ended folks. Not by a long shot.
I've exposed crimes against humanity at the Scottish COVID Inquiry since October 2023 and now when i turn my attention to the UK COVID Inquiry often touted as a whitewash i start to find the same evidence. I cannot for the life of me work out why popular ''medical freedom'' community advocates with MILLIONS of followers between them have not been all over these testimonies. So i ask do we have many doves disgusied as hawks or are there any real white doves left at all? i have my doubts.
https://biologyphenom.substack.com/p/newuk-covid-19-inquiry-28-oct-2024-8d6
https://biologyphenom.substack.com/p/newuk-covid-19-inquiry-28-oct-2024
Please do. THE most important free substack in the world.
It most certainly is THE most important Substack, just stating the facts. The others are loving the attention & looking for the coin from the gullible,imo. Try giving Club Grubbery a go here in Oz with Graham Hood & John Larter or Michael Grey Griffith. This is a battle for humanity.
Very well said Roc. It's a big 'awake' club too. That can clearly be seen on who they support, repost, interview etc Think about it. The lockdown sceptics and protestors from 2020-2021 now have all the official evidence they were right and in 2024 decide to look the other way. https://biologyphenom.substack.com/p/newexclusiveannes-law-consultation
Vaxmania took over
Jessica Hockett gave you a shout-out on a podcast
Which podcast?
I listened to two of them back to back. I think it was this one https://rumble.com/v5rf8ih-jessica-hockett-aka-woodhouse76-covid-researcher..html
If not it would have been one from earlier in the year called the Health Freedom Podcast.
Ok, thanks.
At the end of the day what happened in care homes is the root of the 'pandemic' and therefore exposes the jabs were never required to begin therefore is the bigger crime. All now proven through witness statements from an official public inquiry which has been largely ignored by the world's media including 'alternative' UNLIKE the danger jabs which is an approved narrative. Just scrolled your main page and learned absolutely nothing.
EXAMPLE - ''Dr yeadon…is a fucking shill, he talked about flu, when we were doing coronaviruses”.
Dr yeadon is a shill, he is a shill what a mother fucking shill!!”.
Embarassing!
No Hubris here: "The Most important free Substack". "No. Mine is". No. You're wrong. Mine is". "That's not true. Mine is". I'm sorry guys but you embarrass yourselves with this pissing contest. And Dr. Clare deserves better in the comments addressing her fine work. Just my opinion. Carry on.
It's callled having a sense of humour. It IS the ONLY substack in the world consistently documenting the world's only official COVID inquiry to reveal the truth to the lockdown hearing directly from families. Pretty important stuff in my eyes. Maybe you should take some time to study it and report back on the evidence vs mocking people that are trying to reveal THE truth to the ''COVID'' pandemic. Merry xmas! Have another red pill on me you look like you haven't woken up enough yet.
There is nothing i've seen on your page i didn't already know and have you ever thought maybe it's you who is effected by ''the darkforce'' given the state of your comments?
''JJ coey is a prick, and so is Dr yeadon. ''
You have the most important free substack in the world? Ok mate. We will agree to disagree.
"creating a culture where doctors fail to lead." indeed - the abdication of responsibility and acceptance of the premise that managers manage better than doctors - as if there were a binary choice. Doctors who have good leadership skills should be leading the whole operation with middle managers following orders from people who have clinical experience. Doctors have let this happen, just as PAs and AAs are starting to gain traction in the UK. Sadly there are too many perverse incentives messing things up. Not enough critical thinking of what works, what doesn't, what gives maximal benefit to the patient for least cost. NICE should be a beacon of efficiency, but instead that system isn't working (else cheap repurposed drugs would have been used during "covid". And economies would not have been shut down in the vain hope of postponing a few elderly lives by 6 months. And perhaps NICE is run by those with strong connections to big pharma, who knows.
Thank you Clare for gentle, intelligent and powerful writing and the thinking that goes behind that
I am now 80+ years old. in fair health for my age. I have worked every day until retirement ( forced) from the age of 12 the corner store , meat market and drug store at the same time. I have worked the most foul jobs, loud noise and dirty. smelling of forming oil and smoke. even working with walking pneumonia.
Only retiring because I suffered a damaged back when hit by a car and had to take pain medication. Fords told me I couldn't work because of insurance problems taking pain meds and programming robots. I also worked on my cousins farm every summer until I joined the Navy. I was exposed to everything. even cowpox which left me immune to small pox.
I had every pox and cold virus I caught from my school mates. we went to school sick or not. I tell you this because we as humans must develop our own immune system. injection of an immune response developed in a test tube doesn't work well. nature designed our immune system by millions of years of trial and error. what didn't work was discarded.
Today however it isn't our health that determines what we get. it is profits. when they find something that works well or not it is handed out. then government steps in and regulates it. telling all that it will make us healthier. when it is accepted by the people ignorant of any side effects it becomes a mandate so that we cant refuse treatment. the cost at the start could be missed days of school or a fine for child neglect. now it has all become weaponized.
Covid is the latest example. while it did spread quickly. ( all too quickly for a normal virus ) and did result in some people dying a cure was demanded (to save the world) We were told that it was deadly. (not offering data ) and they were rushing to create the shots to prevent it.
Shortcuts were taken and when one was found it was rushed into production "to save the world" it would be free to all. ( not free but paid for by our taxes ) and all in the panic caused by government propaganda were given the shots. Without proof of it working people ( some who couldnt offer refusal ) were dying without being exposed to the virus.
This was hidden from the people. They continued to Regulate. people who got the virus found it survivable and some didnt even know they had it. proof that nature provided its own way to deal with the virus. government not letting a good crisis go to waste made the shots as a mandate.
Then using misused power it forced companies to demand complience or they would loose their job. Many did and it ruined the lives of many. devorice loss of homes businesses. our rights violated without consequences. Now the WHO wants to have power to demand our complience from a group of people we didnt elect that would take actions up and including military actions if we dont follow their orders.
Again we see the "regulations" put in place to insure our safety. using our health and the rest of the world as reason. They no longer need proof because they have power. power we granted them. power to impose fines and controls that could destroy our nation. I now sit here in disblief on how our nation has gone from relitive freedom to a controling government of both national and world control without resistance.
Control given from fear. developed from the ignorence we have allowed from, again "regulations" that made education "available " to the underprivileged. Our health should be the one thing that is totaly under our control. Now with government "regulations" that become mandates that when not followed become criminal offences.
We still have a choice time to find the reasons for them and who makes these mandates. We must have accountability for our represenatives who willingly violate our rights to have power and control. I lived quite well with out all government mandates. we dont need our lives planned out each step of the way. sorry for being so long in my post. thanks for reading.--------- I, Grampa
Thank you for sharing your experiences and what you learned from them. Our "health" and other aspects of our lives are indeed controlled. You are a hearty person, surviving many assaults.
Thanks Dr. Clare for sharing this insight. The Hawks and Doves... the Hubris of the Hawks. "People without medical training tend to be hawks about medicine", I surely connect with that statement. Even in my own family I have seen and lamented the truth and consequences of that.
Well said Clare. Spot on in all points. Society has been 'dumbed down' for decades and our unconscionable government's going along stock and barrel. Keep up the great work.
Great article, but could you publish it in a heavier type, as it has less IMPACT as it reads, thanks.
A thought-provoking perspective. I agree with the basic idea that pharmaceutical-type intervention vs natural healing or an intervention not likely to cause harm. The pharm industry is indeed way out of hand. Knowledge of healing through letting nature taking a non-dangerous course, or herbs when safe, or food used in an ayurvedic way, has been substantially diminshed to a minority of specialists. In the US this is only rarely allowed in the medical industry. Therefore, expensive. I see the hawk problem though as being caused by extreme powers far above the control and even the knowledge of health care providers, rather than being a direction that providers have taken. Censorship and harsh penalties are used to prevent knowledge and informed response. Leaving the fight to doctors alone won't solve the problem. On a second point, I take issue with the terms "hawk" and "dove". They are biased because of their connotations. I would prefer labels that are descriptive rather than editorial. Nevertheless your concept of "medicine" and public "health" having gone aggressive and harmful is true to my way of thinking.
Super comment Will!! eg-The Scottish COVID inquiry revealled to the world clear as day what the 'COVID pandemic' really was and even THAT cannot muster a collaborative and strong resistance to the false narratives from 2020 which largely have survived in tact. The Scottish evidence i find is consciously AVOIDED by the 'truther/alt media/freedom' community and those that have said something it's token coverage. So many seem to have an agenda self serving or otherwise. Accountability is miles off because no one really wants it. Many happy to take their pieces of silver though ''exposing the truth.''
''“Every kingdom divided against itself is brought to desolation, and every city or house divided against itself will not stand. '' - Jesus--Matthew--2:25
Yes REAL adult debate is the biggest issue missing and now a really serious problem whether it's 'COVID' or climate crisis etc
I agree completely especially in relation to the popular ''freedom'' influencers who remember ARE profiteering quite well from being in this space. Also Neil Oliver's point blank refusal to draw attention to the Scottish COIVD inquiry health and social care closing statements occuring in Edinburgh just 36 miles away from his doorstep in Stirling is extremely revealling. A historian saying nought about all that?!! Wow! I notice GBN just uploaded a new video with Neil about FLOURIDE IN USA tap water and how he is 'stunned.' But CONFIRMED human rights abuses, torture and death of his fellow Scots. Meh? I'll give that a pass. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SRh2I_gK0Uk&ab_channel=GBNews
It isnt paranormal but is evil. I have watched for decades as our children have been "dumed down and taught the facts that government is the answer to all their problems. because so many now that include two to three generations have become dependant upon government that they go willingly for anything gov. says. I have been stifled and even arrested for daring to stand and speak up having documented proof of my statements. Media is no longer a forum we can depend upon to didtribute facts and demand accountability. I now 80 and have so many miles behind me and few left to travel must depend upon others to carry on. I am gled you are there and know what is true. I do hope you find a way to get the words out that will show all the facts you know. I see the major problem is that people dont want to know. they are sadisfied in living their lives in a controled fall, depending upon government to "save" them. One thing you may try to overcome that silence. your words must be newsworthy. something they cant resist at not being first to publish. I am not skilled at knowing what that is. I am sorry. Thank you for your efforts----- I, Grampa
What a beautiful comment.